Scalping vs Day Trading vs Swing Trading or Position Trading ‒ Choose Your Trading Style

BY TIO Staff

|December 12, 2022

Knowing what trading style suits you is a key aspect to trading successfully. There are four types of trading styles which fall under the two categories of short-term trading and long-term trading. In this article we will analyze scalping vs day trading vs swing trading vs position trading and which of these four trading styles is right for you.

Scalping and day trading fall under the category of short-term trading. You may be asking, scalping vs day trading, which one is better? Or, which one is better for you?

The same questions apply for the styles of trading that fall under the category of long-term trading: swing trading vs position trading. Which trading style should you choose?

Every trader needs to find the style that suits their personality best, whether you want to trade stocks, commodities, Forex, or indices. Having said that, you may want to try out different styles of trading before you settle on one type. Once you’ve understood the differences of scalping vs day trading vs swing trading vs position trading, you may also choose to work with two or more different styles. So, let’s dig in a little bit to find out which one, or more, may suit you!

What you will learn about scalping vs day trading vs swing trading vs position trading:

  1. Defining Short-Term Trading
  2. What is Scalping?
  3. What Is Day Trading?
  4. Scalping Vs Day Trading – The 3 Key Differences
  5. What Is The Most Successful Scalping Strategy?
  6. What Is More Profitable, Day Trading Or Scalping?
  7. Defining Long-Term Trading
  8. What Is Swing Trading?
  9. What Is Position Trading?
  10. Swing Trading Vs Position Trading – The 3 Key Differences
  11. Is Scalping Better Than Swing Trading?
  12. What Trading Style Will You Choose?

Defining Short-Term Trading

Short-term trading is a type of trading that involves buying and selling an asset within the same trading day. Short-term traders typically aim to profit from price fluctuations over a period of hours or days, rather than weeks or months. To do this, they try to anticipate and capitalize on intra day momentum, rather than focusing on long-term trends.

Short-term trading can be done with Forex, stocks, indices and commodities like gold or silver. Because short-term traders tend to focus on very small changes in the price of an asset, it’s important for them to have access to real-time information about the prices at which assets are being traded.

The two styles of trading that fall under the category of short-term trading are scalping and day trading.

What is Scalping?

Scalping is a trading style that relies on short-term price fluctuations. It involves making small profits at a high frequency. Traders who employ this strategy tend to open and close positions quickly, usually within minutes or even seconds. Scalpers rely on the ability to make money off of small price movements and are not concerned with holding their positions for longer periods of time.

The key to scalping is having an edge, which means being able to identify patterns in the market quickly. In other cases, it may be as simple as identifying which assets have been trending up or down over time and then using those trends to indicate what direction to trade in. This style of trading is almost exclusively done with technical analysis.

Scalping is one of the most popular trading styles because it allows traders to potentially make money quickly.

The success of this strategy depends on how quickly you can identify opportunities then enter and exit trades. Scalpers must be able to respond quickly when prices change in order to take advantage of short-term opportunities.

What is Day Trading?

Day trading involves the buying and selling of the same security or financial instrument within one day. This style of trading has been popular in recent years, but it’s important to remember that while it can be a successful style, it also carries significant risk.

Elements of Day Trading:

  • Day traders are often looking for opportunities that will allow them to capitalize on short-term price movements. They might buy am asset at a low price and then sell it at a higher price later in the same day.
  • Day traders typically utilize trading signals and other specialized software programs to analyze trades before deciding which ones might rise or fall. They identify patterns in price movements so they can decide when it makes sense to buy or sell an asset before closing out their position later in the same day.
  • Day traders typically specialize and monitor few markets to identify trading opportunities.

The main advantages of day trading are that it allows you to buy low and sell high in a short period of time. Day traders also monitor information frequently so they can react to sudden changes in the market. For example, if there is news about an economic event, this could cause a currency to drop suddenly.

Scalping vs Day Trading – The 3 Key Differences

Scalping vs day trading, which one is better? They are two of the most popular ways to trade, but they’re not the same. Here are the three key differences between them:

1. Scalping is done in a very short time frame, often within minutes or even seconds. Day trading takes place over longer periods of time, usually hours or days.

2. Scalping involves trading in higher frequency, trying to accumulate many small profits from multiple trades in a day. Day trading focuses on making few trades in the day with a slightly larger profit potential on each trade.

3. Scalping requires more presence and screen monitoring than day trading does. Although both styles require active management of trades, day trading is less intensive.

FAQ: What is the most successful scalping strategy?

The most successful scalping strategy is one that allows you to trade in high frequency throughout the day and has a high win rate. Since risk to reward ratios are generally low for scalping strategies.

FAQ: What’s more profitable day trading or scalping?

Day trading and scalping are both short-term trading strategies. Depending on your preferences you may find one to be better than the other. However, many day traders will tell you that they prefer day trading over scalping since day trading may not involve opening as many trades in a day as scalping might.

Defining Long-Term Trading

Long-term trading is a form of investing that involves holding positions for a long time, usually months or years.

Long-term traders are often able to take advantage of the fact that markets tend to move in cycles. They may buy an asset when it’s low and hold it until it increases in value, months or years down the line. The profit potential from long term trading can be quite significant but opportunities may be few throughout the year.

Long-term trading requires patience since you need to be willing to wait out adverse price movements. You also need to be disciplined and stick with your plan regardless of what happens in the short term.

The two styles of trading that fall under the category of long-term trading are swing trading and position trading. Although most swing trades are held for durations covering the medium term.

What is Swing Trading?

Swing trading typically involves buying and selling assets over periods of days and weeks. The goal is to make a profit from the up-and-down price fluctuations in the medium term. Swing traders believe that it’s possible to make money over days or weeks trading; rather than just holding onto assets for months or years.

Several factors make swing trading a good option for many investors. Those looking for a side-hustle find swing trade as a part-time job an attractive style.

  • Swing trading can be a great way to diversify your portfolio by reducing risk and adding more opportunities for gains. If you have multiple positions in uncorrelated markets, this can help you hedge against losses if one position fails.
  • Swing traders often hold their positions for longer periods than day traders. They are inclined to hold and ride out any sudden short term market fluctuations or events.
  • Swing traders also tend to be more cautious about what trades they open. They are patient and wait for the most opportune times to trade.

What is Position Trading?

Position trading is the practice of buying and selling assets based on long-term trends. It involves taking a long-term view of the market; then making investments with the intention of holding them for several months or even years.

Position traders are typically more interested in identifying opportunities than reacting to them. This allows them to maintain their positions even if there are short-term adverse fluctuations in the market.

Position trading can be successful if you have a strong understanding of how markets work; additionally you must understand how different asset classes behave under different economic conditions. Diversification may also be a part of a position traders strategy. Their portfolios may include many assets that are not correlated with each other.

Swing Trading vs Position Trading – The 3 key differences

The two long-term trading styles are swing trading and position trading, but they differ in three key ways:

  1. Traders who swing trade use technical indicators to determine when to enter and exit the market more than they do the fundamentals. Position traders use fundamental analysis more to determine when to enter and exit the market.
  2. The style of Swing trading involves buying assets at a low price; then selling them at a high price within a short time period (usually 1-4 days). Position trading involves buying assets at a low price; then holding onto them for an extended period of time (a few months or even years).
  3. Swing traders typically have lower risk profile than position traders since their trades are shorter term and can involve less capital. Position traders have higher risk since their trades are long term and may involve larger sums of money.

FAQ: Is Scalping Better Than Swing Trading?

Scalping is a high-frequency trading strategy that involves making small profits by frequently buying and selling financial instruments. It is an extremely risky strategy because it requires traders to be right often enough to offset the losses they incur on failed trades.

Unlike scalping, swing trading involves holding positions for days or weeks, rather than minutes or hours. This means that swing traders have fewer opportunities to capitalize on price changes. It also means that they may have more risk associated with each trade.

What Trading Style Will You Choose?

So we’ve analyzed scalping vs day trading vs swing trading and position trading. And now you may be wondering which one to choose.

Each style has its own way of analyzing the market. Your trading psychology and personality may work well with one or more trading style depending on your analytical skills and tolerance to risk.

The trading style you resonate with can help you determine what type of market to trade in; what time frames to trade on, and how much risk management you will use when trading. You must find a strategy and style that fits your personality and trading goals. This will help you have a better chance at succeeding as a trader.

Which Style Fits You Best?

Trading styles are all about finding the one that fits you best. You might have a low tolerance to risk and be more patient. Either way, it’s important to find what works for your personality and trading objectives.

When choosing your trading style, start with a demo account. You can test out different strategies without having any real money at stake. Once you’ve tried out different strategies and found one that works for you, you can open an account with real money and start trading!

Take Notes to Figure Out Your Trading Style

While testing out these different styles, remember to take notes in your trading journal. You’ll want to write down what worked well, what didn’t work well; and how much profit or loss was made from each strategy. When it comes time to choose which one is best for your personal style of trading, it will be easier to decide.

Are you ready to start trading? Want to try out a risk-free demo account first? Or do you feel you have enough experience to put some real money into trading on a live account? Get started trading Forex, stocks, indices and commodities today with TIOmarkets, a top rated broker.

Risk disclaimer: CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage. You should consider whether you understand how CFDs work and whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money. Never deposit more than you are prepared to lose. Professional client’s losses can exceed their deposit. Please see our risk warning policy and seek independent professional advice if you do not fully understand. This information is not directed or intended for distribution to or use by residents of certain countries/jurisdictions including, but not limited to, USA & OFAC. The Company holds the right to alter the aforementioned list of countries at its own discretion.

TIO Staff
24/7 Live Chat

Trade responsibly: CFDs are complex instruments and come with a high risk of losing all your invested capital due to leverage.